
There are times when I wish I knew more about cooking, especially seasoning. Even with more than a decade of food blogs under my belt, there are times where I don’t have the words to do justice to the flavors that I’m tasting.
That’s the case with the beef legume from Sizzling Island Creole Caribbean Cuisine, one of my favorite stands at the Fairgrounds Farmers Market.
I first tried Sizzling Island in the fall of 2024 while they were operating a second location inside the Reading Downtown Food Court.

This wasn’t just my introduction to Sizzling Island, but it was my introduction to beef legume, the delicious Haitian stew that I instantly loved. In my Instagram post at the time, I described it as “bursting with flavor,” the most detailed description I could give.
The downtown location closed in late 2024, but the Fairgrounds location is still going strong. I visited the market stand during the summer of 2026. When I arrived, there was a short line ahead of me – a group of four college students who just barely beat me to the stand.

Sizzling Island is at the north end of the market near the Bellevue Avenue entrance. The stand looks a bit chaotic. Flags of countries in Central and South America hang above the order counter. There’s a faux-roof on the stand, green metal sheeting that matches the artificial turf that covers a small wall at the end of the stand. Along the base of the order counter were woven potholders and a pair of potted plants.
I placed my order – beef legume with a side of plantains – and waited. Most of the food at Sizzling Island can be found on the steamer table. A variety of stews, soups and sides sizzle in the pans. However, there were no plantains ready so all I could do was wait.
I normally eat an early lunch so with the clock passing 12:30, I was extra hungry. It was only 15 minutes from the time I ordered until I had my food, but if you had told me a half-hour had passed, I would have believed you.

The beef legume was everything that I remembered it being. The beef was melt-in-your-mouth tender with bursts of flavor – garlic, peppers and other mild spices – in every bite.
The “legume” part is a mostly mashed vegetable medley that the beef is stewed in. It’s not the prettiest dish to look at as it takes on a green-yellow hue from the spinach with little pops of orange from the larger pieces of carrots that haven’t been mashed up.
I don’t really care what it looks like, it tastes amazing.
On the side, I had black rice (duri djon djon), another Haitian specialty. Sizzling Island’s version uses long-grain rice with green peas that have been cooked with even more seasonings and spices to give it a unique flavor of its own.
The plantains, unfortunately, were not as sweet as I had hoped for. They were OK, but I wished I had ordered something that was already on the warming table instead of waiting for the plantains.
The beef legume meal cost $19. It’s on the higher side for the market, but the portion was enough for two meals so I felt like I got more than my money’s worth.
I may not be able to tell you every flavor or every spice I tasted at Sizzling Island, but I can tell you the food is worth trying for yourself.
BCE Rating
Food: Very Good
Service: Good
Ambiance: Fair
Price: $$
Sizzling Island at the Fairgrounds Farmers Market
2934 N. 5th Street Highway
Reading, PA 19605

































































