Panevino – CLOSED

Editor’s Note: Panevino is now a special events host and catering company. The business moved to Wernersville in 2021 where it operates a small venue and offers event catering.

The Goggleworks has truly been a blessing to the City of Reading. Thanks to this community arts center, the neighborhood has truly blossomed into the city’s cultural district. Reading Area Community College opened the Miller Center for the Arts in 2007 and the IMAX theater opened a year later. 

What the area lacked was a signature restaurant, a place to go before or after the cinematic, musical and theatrical events taking place every night.

That changed in 2011 with the opening of Panevino.

The restaurant actually sits under the Washington Street parking garage, directly across the street from the IMAX theater. It’s nothing glamorous from the outside, but it’s beautiful on the inside with low lighting, fine china and glassware, and modern styling.

Self-described as “rustic Italian cuisine,” the menu mixes traditional favorites like rigatoni and thin crust pizza with Panevino’s unique dishes, like the straw and hay – spinach and egg fettuccini served with lamb meatballs, eggplant, tomato, raisins and pine nuts.

Every meal is served with a unique appetizer I have never had anywhere else. It is served in two parts to eat together or separate. The first is a slice of bread – more closely resembling a thick pizza crust – topped with fresh tomatoes. The second, a wedge of polenta and a thin slice of roast beef, drizzled with balsamic vinaigrette. It seemed like an odd pairing, but somehow it worked. All of the flavors blended nicely together.

I started my meal with a bowl of pasta fagioli, a staple on any Italian menu, and a great indicator of the meal to come. The fagioli is served in a small crock, a paper doily resting underneath. It was very good, sweet and spicy, meaty with a hearty serving of beans. The dish was completed with thin cut slices of farfalle pasta, one of the many pastas Panevino makes from scratch.

Salads have never been my favorite, but I had to try the Arugula, a mixture of arugula leaves, pears, gorgonzola and leafy greens drizzled with white balsamic vinaigrette, and served in a parmesan bowl. Despite my general disdain for salad, I found myself enjoying this, especially the edible bowl. The parmesan flavor was strong and concentrated, much more so than the flavor of grated parmesan. The closest thing to compare it to is the pre-packaged breadsticks some restaurants serve, but with a better, fresher, stronger (sometimes a little too strong) flavor.

There was a long wait in between courses, not unexpected because every dish is prepared fresh. Panevino is not a diner. It’s dining – a living reminder of the old adage, “good things come to those who wait.”

Salads have never been my favorite, but I had to try the Arugula, a mixture of arugula leaves, pears, gorgonzola and leafy greens drizzled with white balsamic vinaigrette, and served in a parmesan bowl. Despite my general disdain for salad, I found myself enjoying this, especially the edible bowl. The parmesan flavor was strong and concentrated, much more so than the flavor of grated parmesan. The closest thing to compare it to is the pre-packaged breadsticks some restaurants serve, but with a better, fresher, stronger (sometimes a little too strong) flavor.

There was a long wait in between courses, not unexpected because every dish is prepared fresh. Panevino is not a diner. It’s dining – a living reminder of the old adage, “good things come to those who wait.”

That didn’t stop me from ordering dessert, a warm piece of pecan pie with caramel drizzle and vanilla ice cream – good, but nothing special as far as pies go. The crust was a little overcooked, but the ice cream hid it well.   

The wait staff worked as a team – at times this was helpful, and at times it wasn’t. At the end of the night, it took long time for us to get our bill, and two separate team members wanted to take our dessert order.

For all the food we got – two entrees, a cup of soup and dessert – the bill was surprisingly reasonable, about $25 per person. With the delicious food in a fine dining atmosphere, it was $50 well spent.  

More Italian Restaurants in Berks County

More Restaurants in Reading, PA

Closed

The Steak Shack – CLOSED

Editor’s Note: After moving twice, the Steak Shack is now closed. The last location was inside the CITGO station on Lancaster Avenue in Reading. That location closed in 2021.

seating area with an illuminated sign reading "The Steak Shack" beneath banners of athletes

For some restaurants, it’s the location that makes it special, like a country restaurant with a riverside view. For others, it’s the ambiance: a rustic inn with  Victorian furnishings or an upscale wine bar with chic modern style.

When the Steak Shack opened three years ago, it was, quite literally, a shack. The small wooden structure was set in a parking lot along Route 61 in Leesport. Surrounded on one side by a roadside flower stand, and a utility shed salesman on the other, the location was less than ideal.

So last year the Steak Shack packed up and moved inside Body Zone Sports & Wellness Complex, just off Route 222 on Paper Mill Road.

Now instead of watching cars pass by on the highway, you can enjoy your dinner while watching amateur hour on one of Body Zone’s ice rinks. The view is great, if you enjoy middle age Mennonite men trying to play ice hockey in jeans.

But while the Steak Shack has always lacked in ambiance and location, it has always delivered on the two things that matter most: food and service.

I knew from its time in Leesport that the Steak Shack is Cash Only, but I somehow managed to forget until after I placed my order. A walk to the ATM at the entrance of Body Zone proved useless – instead of the $20 I asked for, I got a “communication error.”

With my tail between my legs, I returned to the counter with four $1 bills and $2 in change, all that I had on my person.

“Don’t worry about it,” the cashier said as I emptied my pockets. I insisted on downsizing my order, but he refused. “I’m owner,” he said, “Don’t worry about it. I want to make repeat customers.”

This above-and-beyond personal service can only be found in small, local establishments, and it’s one of the reasons that I am loyal to the Steak Shack. The other reason is just as important: the food.

The sign proclaims “Authentic Philly Cheesesteaks,” and that’s what the Steak Shack delivers. The meat is sliced thin, and cooked to perfection. Rather than choose from the selection of cheeses (American, Swiss, Provolone, American Whiz or Cheddar Whiz), I took my steak sandwich with sauce and onion.

tray with a steak sandwich, boat of fries and a drink in a paper Coca-Cola cup

There’s something about the Steak Shack’s sauce that just blends well with the other ingredients. The sauce is the perfect texture – not thick like a marinara sauce, but thick enough that it doesn’t run out of the roll. And the roll itself is ideal: soft on the inside, but with a crunch on the outside so it’s sturdy enough to hold everything together until you’re finished.

Then there are the fries. At Leesport they were short, thick “race track” fries, but now they’re cut thin like fast food restaurants. But the flavor is still the same – a fresh-cut flavor with a little grease. Add a little vinegar and the fries reach a whole new level.

Other menu items at the Shack include chicken cheesesteaks, homemade potato chips, and New York style pizza with over 25 available toppings. When another customer asked about the chicken cheesesteaks, the owner summed up why the Shack is the best. “We use real chicken, not that processed stuff,” he said. “If you don’t like it, I’ll give you your money back.” The Steak Shack takes pride in its food, and it has a lot to be proud of.

The Shack is open seven days a week for lunch and dinner. Just remember to bring cash. Even if the ATM is working, it’s a $2.50 surcharge.

Want to share your own experience? Have a suggestion for where I should go next? Leave a message in the comments section, or tweet using #BerksCountyEats

Closed

Risser’s Family Restaurant – CLOSED

Risser’s Family Restaurant closed in 2014 following the death of namesake owner Ernie Risser. It was succeeded by a pair of restaurants, but the original dining car has been sold and moved to a campground in northern Pennsylvania.

Cooking with a Touch of Pennsylvania Dutch: The words are printed on the mural that spans the dining room wall at Risser’s Family Restaurant in Stouchsburg. The wall is covered with Amish farm scenes and proverbs like “Kissing wears out, cooking don’t” and “we grow too soon old, and too late schmart.”

Part diner, part family restaurant, Risser’s has been serving local favorites in western Berks County for decades. The original dining car opened in 1954 as the Blue Star Diner, and it still maintains its retro styling, with stainless steel trim on the counter and stools. The dining room has a more rustic feel, with the mural on one wall and country primitives throughout.

One of the highlights of dinner at Risser’s is the soup and salad bar that comes with most meals. Six varieties of soups, from chicken noodle to clam chowder, are available on any given night. The salad bar includes more than 10 different dressings-including hot bacon dressing, homemade macaroni and potato salad, and some of the best red beet eggs anywhere. Fresh baked muffins and breads are also included.

And with every salad bar order comes soft ice cream, vanilla and chocolate, with topping options that include chocolate syrup, crushed Oreo cookies, peanuts, and chocolate sprinkles.

Risser’s has all the standard diner fare: french toast, pancakes, and omelets at breakfast; soups and sandwiches at lunch, and meat and potato platters at dinner.

But Risser’s specialty is traditional Pennsylvania Dutch entrees: chicken pot pie, pig stomach, beef heart, and a personal favorite, schnitz und knepp – warm, baked apples served with a dumpling and four thick slices of baked ham.

slices of ham atop a bed of apples in a boat with dumplings

The flavor combination is unexpected, a mix of dinner and dessert. As the dumpling soaks up the glaze from the apples, it tastes more and more like apple pie. The saltiness of ham is a strange, but welcome addition to the dish, and it only gets better as the ingredients have time to blend together. The only downside to the dish is that it’s only offered every few weeks as a special, and is not part of the daily menu.

If you’re looking for the unique taste of Pennsylvania Dutch cooking, Risser’s is a great choice. Entrees run between $10-$15, and many are available in small and large portions. Check their website or local ads for weekly and daily specials.

Closed

Hall of Flame BBQ & Wings – CLOSED

Hall of Flame BBQ & Wings is now closed. The restaurant closed in 2013.

Hall of Flame BBQ & Wings is the latest edition to Berks County’s growing list of barbecue restaurants. Opening in late 2012 in the former Pizza Time building on Lancaster Avenue, the Hall of Flame specializes in wood-smoked meats and deep fried chicken wings.

A plain white and brown exterior is not nearly as appealing as the smells coming from inside. A small counter sits in front of the kitchen area, which is in full view of customers.

A couple other customers were standing by the counter waiting for their food. One of them sampled one of Hall of Flame’s fatality wings, which he managed to eat without taking a drink. He raved about the flavor of the wing, and how you got the heat without the messy sauce.

I wasn’t nearly as brave, but my black cherry habanero BBQ wings were the highlight of the meal. The wings were deep fried to perfection, and the sauce was one of the best I have ever tasted, with an incredible sweetness from the cherries, and a slow burn from the habanero that built up as I tore through my order.

styrofoam clamshell with six wings, celery and bleu cheese

For the main course, I chose the Hall of Famer sandwich, an oversized roll loaded with beef brisket and pulled pork, with potato wedges on the side. The meats were tender and flavored well, but the brisket still had some fat on it, and there was just too much meat for the tiny cup of sauce that came with it. A little more sauce would have made a world of difference.

open face sandwich with brisket and pork with a side of potato wedges and a side of coleslaw

The wedges were about six inches long and golden brown, but I was expecting more flavor. There are several seasoned and loaded options that I would suggest trying instead.

The Hall of Flame’s most intriguing menu item is the BBQ parfait, a monstrous mountain of barbecue, sides, and cheese sauce.

cup with layers of meat, coleslaw and cheese sauce

“I don’t sell too many of them,” the owner told me when he delivered the parfait, “but it’s more of a novelty item. You can’t get it anywhere else.”

The parfait starts with your choice of side dish on the bottom, then it gets covered in BBQ and cheese sauces, followed by your choice of meat and more sauces. The whole thing is topped off with a big scoop of coleslaw.

It’s definitely not for everyone. The flavor combination is interesting to say the least. The coleslaw can be overpowering as its flavor seeps into the whole dish. If you don’t like coleslaw, you’re not going to like it. If you do like it, and you like trying new things, give the dish a try. For $5.95, it’s worth it to say to you ate a BBQ parfait.

Sandwiches range from $6-9, while BBQ platters run $9-23. The Hall of Flame has only three tables so it’s best to plan for take-out. Wing prices vary depending on quantity. Open seven days a week until 10:00 pm.

Closed

Muddy’s BBQ – CLOSED

Editor’s Note: Muddy’s BBQ is closed. After moving to a brick-and-mortar location, the restaurant closed in 2017 with the owner citing health concerns.

The smell of barbecue wafts through the air along Route 12. About a mile south of the Route 73 intersection, a small trailer sits on the side of a hill. Parked cars line the narrow stone driveway that winds its way around. Dozens of people are crammed around the five adjacent picnic tables as they devour beef brisket and pulled pork that took hours to slow cook.

A sign along Pricetown Road points the passing cars to Muddy’s BBQ, one of Berks County’s newest dining hot spots. March 1st began the outdoor barbecue joint’s sophomore season of business, with fans flocking in after a township-induced four-month fast from the tender meats that Muddy’s began serving up at this spot in the Spring of 2011.

In the south, places like Muddy’s are everywhere. I fell in love with barbecue five years ago on a trip to the Gulf Coast. There, outside the otherwise sleepy little town of Oceans Springs, Mississippi, I found The Shed, a literal shed in middle of nowhere that had people lined up for over an hour just order. Since then, I’ve eaten in barbecue joints from Texas to North Carolina to New York City, unsuccessfully trying to find something that could rival The Shed. Never did I dream I would be able to find it in the Oley Valley.

While you wait in line, the smell can drive you crazy. If you go during peak hours, you could be waiting to order for fifteen minutes to a half hour before waiting just as long for your food. But a little patience goes a long way.

Pulled-Pork-Platter-Muddy-s-BBQ

On my most recent trip, I decided on a platter of pulled pork with a side of french fries and barbecue baked beans. Each platter comes with two slices of white bread, which come in very handy for cleaning up extra sauce.

Their pulled pork, like all their meat, is slow-cooked and I can just imagine it falling apart as they prepare it. It’s tender and juicy, but a little extra sauce never hurts. The fries are fresh-cut and dashed with Old Bay. The uneven coating gives a little different flavor in each bite. The baked beans are some of the best around. Whatever is left from yesterday’s meats get thrown in with the beans. It almost has the consistency of chili, but the much sweeter flavor of barbecue.

If you want to give Muddy’s a try, start with lunch if you can. It’s not as full, and you can usually find an open seat on the picnic tables. If you’re going for dinner, especially on the weekend, you’re either going to have to take your food home with you, or make new friends because the tables are full through the whole dinner rush.

My meal cost about $12 including the drink. Sandwiches are a more economical option, and come with slaw and a side for a few dollars less. For families, Muddy’s offers several combos that can be shared, including The Feast, which features almost everything on the menu, can feed five or more, and runs about $60.

Closed