Updated: February 2021

In six years of Berks County Eats, we have tried pizza from more than 30 area restaurants. While there are still plenty more to go, these five are the favorites we have found so far:

Best Pizza: Nonno Alby's

Nonno Alby’s Brick Oven Pizza

Nonno Alby’s was really the first restaurant to bring artisan, brick oven pizza to Berks County, and they still do it better than anyone else. The namesake Nonno Alby’s pizza is probably my favorite around. Read Review

The Original Mama’s Pizza

The Original Mama’s Pizza has two locations – Sinking Spring and Wyomissing – and neither have ever let us down. Their traditional pies are very good, but we also like their stuffed slices for a quick lunch or dinner.  Read Review

Romano’s Chicago Style Pizza

Deep-dish pizza is not the norm in Berks County so when I found Romano’s in 2014, I was very excited. Their Chicago-style pie did not disappoint and remains a favorite of ours to this day. Read Review

Sal's Pizza Style Stromboli Pizza

Sal’s Pizza Style

Sal’s is your typical neighborhood pizza place, but with exceptional service and the one-of-a-kind pizza Stromboli that everyone should try at least once. Read Review

Tony's al Taglio Pizza

Tony’s al Taglio

Tony’s al Taglio is one of the newer pizza places in Berks County and also its most unique. While others sell pies by the slice, Tony’s sells by the strip. It’s a unique concept. It’s convenient. And it also tastes amazing. Read Review

Honorable Mentions

P&J’s Pizza, Womelsdorf: P&J’s was our go-to pizza place when I was growing up in western Berks and still a go-to for our family when we visit (the sandwiches are excellent, too). Read Review

TommyBoy’s Pizza & Cafe, Kutztown: TommyBoy’s not only has good pizza, but they have “bigger-than-your-face” slices. Read Review

Russo Gourmet Foods Market, Shillington: Russo has some of the best Italian food in Berks County (which is why they supply so many other places) and the thick-crust pizza slices available in the market are very good, as well. Read Review

Paradise by the Slice, Wernersville: A multi-time award winner for their pizza, Paradise by the Slice definitely has earned the accolades. Read Review

Bella’s Subs and Pizza, Wyomissing: Located practically next door to Mama’s (see above), I haven’t had Bella’s near as much, but I always have enjoyed it – especially the grandma pizza. Read Review

Want more? Browse all of our pizza reviews here.

Have a favorite pizza place in Berks County we need to try? Tell us about it in the comments or email us at berkscountyeats@gmail.com